Caballo Sentado
I have spent some months reading your posts & not answering any, but I DO want to answer this. Neo Madman gave you an excelent reason for not believing WT allegations, but you dodge the question, is that the way you reason?, that is faulty reasoning.
I don't think I dodged the question. I posed the question, "Were you that stupid all those years you were in the truth?" It is a reasonable question I think. And, apparently the answer for some of you is yes. So, my next question is, if you were that stupid then, what makes you trust your own judgment on matters now? From my standpoint, then, those who have left the truth are the ones with the credibility problem, not those who remain.
That kind of answers are only satisfactory in YOUR mind, you HAVE TO PROVE that there is connection between the WT & God... THEN we believe you.
Again, I would bring the issue back to those who were in the truth for many years. Were you so completely blinded? Did you never have any personal connection to Jehovah God the whole time you were one of Jehovah's Witnesses? Many of you spent years preaching and convincing others that we had the truth. Yet, now you say there is no evidence? That is preposterous. I don't think any of you are being honest with yourselves. I can defend my faith on any topic of your choosing using the Bible and the Bible only. Why can't you do that?
Besides, when you were in the truth did you never experince the flow of God's holy spirit? If not, that would explain your disbelief? Let's face it, not all of Jehovah's Witnesses have a personal relationship with Jehovah, but many do. Those who do are in the truth. And the Watchtower has served as an instrumentality by introducing us to God and Christ. That's all the Watchtower is really supposed to do. Everything else is just chaff as far as I am concerned. The Watchtower has provided the doctrinal basis for that relationship, that have clearly set the vital issues before us, but it is up to each individual to "prove to themselves the good, and acceptable, and perfect will of God." No one can do that for you, you must do it for yourself as an act of will.
You say "It is more reasonable to believe that you are faithless", I DO have faith in God...please be reasonable & give Neo Madman a satisfactory answer, not for your mind, but for all the minds that are reading your posts. If this language was my native one, I could have a better argument with you...
I think you have allowed yourself to be stumbled by the failings of the Watchtower. That's a shame. My heart goes out to you. And I think the brothers at Bethel have a lot to answer to God about. But, I have tried my best to try and snatch those who can be saved out of the fires of doubt. But, let's face it: Most of those who have left couldn't care any less about Jehovah or the future that he has promised. Many of you are immoral and love living for the moment in the Devil's world. For those like yourself who seem to want answers but who just can't seem to sort it out, I think your best shot at getting these issues sorted out will be during the tribulation. As long as you don't go completely berserk before then I think it is possible that some of you might be able to come to your senses when Jehovah rocks the heavens and the earth in preparation for gather his "desirable thigs." / You Know